Block Out vs Silk Eye Masks: Which Sleep Better?
By Kip&Co: Fun, colourful and stylish bedding, homewares ... | Published: 2026-10-13
Category: Comparisons
Compare a block out silk eye mask and a pure silk eye mask on light blocking, skin feel, and fit. Learn which design suits your sleep and travel needs.
Quick answer
Choose a block out silk eye mask if you need maximum darkness for deeper, uninterrupted rest. Choose a pure silk eye mask if you want a lighter, breathable feel and gentle protection for lashes and skin. Both rely on mulberry silk, but the block out design adds a light-blocking layer that changes the trade-off between darkness and weight.
Light blocking: the main difference
The Cottage Garden Block Out Silk Eye Mask is designed to block light and reduce friction, which helps create deeper, more restful sleep. The Perfect Pink Silk Eye Mask does not list a light-blocking layer; it focuses on a smooth, skin-loving mulberry silk feel. If you sleep in a bright room or travel on daytime flights, the block out design has a clear advantage. If you only need a soft barrier against light, the pure silk mask may be enough.
Skin and hair feel
Both masks use mulberry silk, which is gentle on skin and helps minimise sleep creases. The Perfect Pink mask adds a silk-covered elastic stretch headband that is safe for your hair, reducing pulling or snagging. The Cottage Garden mask also reduces friction, but its light-blocking design may feel slightly more substantial on the face. If you have sensitive skin or want to protect a hairstyle, the silk-covered band is a practical detail to weigh.
Fit and adjustment
Both masks come in size options, so check the size guide before ordering. A block out mask needs a close fit to seal out light, but too much pressure can feel uncomfortable. A pure silk mask is more forgiving if you move around in bed. If you share a bed with a restless sleeper or often sleep on your side, consider how the mask stays in place. The elastic headband on the Perfect Pink mask is designed for secure bedtime use, while the Cottage Garden mask relies on its overall fit to block light.
Travel and everyday use
For travel, a block out eye mask is often the better choice because it can help you sleep in unfamiliar, bright environments. The Cottage Garden mask is priced at USD 57.67 (compare at USD 79.00), while the Perfect Pink mask is USD 33.55 (compare at USD 55.00). If you want a single mask for home and travel, the block out option covers more scenarios. If you prefer a lighter mask for home naps or as a backup, the pure silk option is easier on the budget.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Light blocking vs breathability: The block out mask adds a light-blocking layer for deeper darkness, but it may feel warmer or heavier than a pure silk mask. Choose block out if darkness matters most; choose pure silk if you overheat easily.
- Price vs features: The Perfect Pink mask costs less and includes a silk-covered elastic band, while the Cottage Garden mask costs more for its light-blocking design. Set your budget and decide whether light blocking is worth the extra cost.
- Fit and adjustment: Both masks come in size options. A block out mask needs a close seal, which can feel tight; a pure silk mask is more forgiving but may let in more light. Check the size guide and prioritize comfort if you move a lot in sleep.
Product facts
- Cottage Garden Block Out Silk Eye Mask: Cottage Garden Block Out Silk Eye Mask: Mulberry silk, light-blocking design, gentle on skin to help minimise sleep creases. Best for sleepers who need darkness to fall asleep faster and stay asleep, especially in bright rooms or during travel.
- Perfect Pink Silk Eye Mask: Perfect Pink Silk Eye Mask: 100% mulberry silk with silk-covered elastic stretch headband for secure bedtime use that is safe for your hair. A lighter, hair-friendly option for those who want silk benefits without a light-blocking layer.
Which should you choose?
Best for
- Side sleepers who need a close-fitting mask to block light
- Travelers dealing with bright hotel rooms or daytime flights
- Anyone who wants to minimize sleep creases and protect lashes
Not for
- Sleepers who prefer a very lightweight, barely-there feel
- Those who overheat easily and need maximum breathability
- Shoppers looking for the lowest-cost silk eye mask
